Skip to content
Toffee Cream Pie

Toffee Cream Pie

  • Makes: 8 servings  
  • Prep Time: 20 minutes 
  • Cooking Time: 20 minutes 
  • Baking Time: 40 minutes 
  • Freezing: not recommended 

Ingredients

Pie Crust

2 cups 500 mL Robin Hood® Original All Purpose Flour

1 cup 250 mL All Vegetable Shortening

1 egg

2 tbsp 30 mL cold water

1 tbsp 15 mL white vinegar

Filling

½ cup 125 mL butter

1 cup 250 mL packed brown sugar

1 cup 250 mL boiling water

1 can Carnation® Regular, 2% or Fat-Free Evaporated Milk

3 tbsp 45 mL Robin Hood® Original All Purpose Flour

3 eggs

1 tsp 5 mL vanilla extract

Topping

1 cup 250 mL whipping cream

2 tbsp 30 mL icing sugar

Directions

  1 Preheat oven to 375°F (190°C).

  2 Pie Crust: Combine flour and salt in mixing bowl. Cut shortening into flour with pastry blender or two knives until mixture resembles coarse crumbs. Beat egg, water and vinegar to blend. Pour over flour mixture. Stir with fork until mixture is moistened. Divide dough in half and shape into a ball. Flatten each into a circle about 4” (10 cm). Wrap and chill dough 15 minutes for easier rolling. Set aside 1 portion of dough for another use. Roll out dough on a floured surface into a circle about 1” (2.5 cm) larger than 9” (23 cm) pie plate. Place into pie plate and flute edges as desired.

  3 Line unbaked pie crust with parchment paper. Fill empty pie crust with pie weights, beans or rice. This weighs down the empty pie crust while baking. Bake in preheated oven 20 minutes. Remove pie weights and parchment paper and continue baking for additional 20 minutes or until golden. Remove from oven.

  4 Filling: Crack eggs into a heat proof bowl. Set aside. Melt butter in a medium sauce pan on medium low heat. Stir until golden. Add brown sugar. Stir constantly for 2-3 minutes until well combined. Add boiling water; be careful mixture will bubble up. Add evaporated milk and flour. Stir constantly until mixture thickens. Remove from heat. Whisk about ¼ cup (50 mL) hot mixture into eggs. This will prevent curdling when adding eggs into hot milk mixture. Pour egg mixture into hot milk mixture and continue cooking, stirring constantly until mixture starts to boil. Cook for another minute. Remove from heat and stir in vanilla. Pour into baked pie shell. Cool and refrigerate until ready to serve.

  5 Topping: Place whipping cream in a medium mixing bowl. Beat until soft peaks form. Add icing sugar. Cover top of pie with whipped cream.

More recipes you’ll love

  • Easy Leche Flan
    Easy Leche Flan

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Tres Leches Cake with Strawberries
    Tres Leches Cake with Strawberries

    Prep Time:
    40 minutes

  • Peach Melba Dutch Baby Pancake
    Peach Melba Dutch Baby Pancake

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Blueberry Lemon Layer Cake
    Blueberry Lemon Layer Cake

    Prep Time:
    1 hour

  • Easy Creamy Crème Brule
    Easy Creamy Crème Brule

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake
    Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Giant Peanut Butter Glazed Donuts
    Giant Peanut Butter Glazed Donuts

    Prep Time:
    45 minutes

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes

  • Chocolate Shortbread Sandwich Cookies
    Chocolate Shortbread Sandwich Cookies

    Prep Time:
    45 minutes

  • Apple Raisin Cinnamon Scones
    Apple Raisin Cinnamon Scones

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Peach Panna Cotta
    Peach Panna Cotta

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

  • Easy Fraisier
    Easy Fraisier

    Prep Time:
    2 hours

  • Tres Leches Cake
    Tres Leches Cake

    Prep Time:
    40 minutes

  • Sweet Cherry & Dark Chocolate Scones
    Sweet Cherry & Dark Chocolate Scones

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Strawberry and White Chocolate Cream Pie
    Strawberry and White Chocolate Cream Pie

    Prep Time:
    40 minutes

  • Light and Fluffy Waffles
    Light and Fluffy Waffles

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

  • Blueberry Burst Orange Loaf
    Blueberry Burst Orange Loaf

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Stuffed Chocolate Cupcakes
    Stuffed Chocolate Cupcakes

    Prep Time:
    35 minutes

  • Mini Raspberry Swirl Cheesecakes
    Mini Raspberry Swirl Cheesecakes

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes

  • Pecan Praline Candy
    Pecan Praline Candy

    Prep Time:
    40 minutes

    Cook Time:
    15 minutes

  • Extra Chocolatey Chocolate Cake
    Extra Chocolatey Chocolate Cake

    Prep Time:
    30 minutes

  • Apple Sticky Toffee Pudding
    Apple Sticky Toffee Pudding

    Prep Time:
    30 minutes

  • Easy Glazed Pumpkin Pie Scones
    Easy Glazed Pumpkin Pie Scones

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Plum Shortcakes
    Plum Shortcakes

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Fresh Peach and Cherry Upside Down Cake
    Fresh Peach and Cherry Upside Down Cake

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes

  • Plum Clafouti
    Plum Clafouti

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • White Chocolate Strawberry Scones
    White Chocolate Strawberry Scones

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Creamy Maple Pie
    Creamy Maple Pie

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Maple Syrup Muffins
    Maple Syrup Muffins

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

  • Maple Walnut Banana Bread
    Maple Walnut Banana Bread

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

  • Sweet Waffle Fingers On A Stick
    Sweet Waffle Fingers On A Stick

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    5 minutes

  • Peach Clafouti
    Peach Clafouti

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Berry & White Chocolate Scones
    Berry & White Chocolate Scones

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Chocolate S’mores Mug Cake
    Chocolate S’mores Mug Cake

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

  • Lemon Pudding Cakes
    Lemon Pudding Cakes

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Fall Harvest Apple Flan
    Fall Harvest Apple Flan

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes (includes cooking apples)

    Cook Time:
    50-55 minutes

  • Creamy Fruit Filled Cream Puffs
    Creamy Fruit Filled Cream Puffs

    Prep Time:
    45 minutes

  • Coconut Cream Pie
    Coconut Cream Pie

    Prep Time:
    30 minutes plus chilling time

  • Cherry Clafouti
    Cherry Clafouti

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Pear & Walnut Galette
    Pear & Walnut Galette

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes

  • Chocolate Cream Pie
    Chocolate Cream Pie

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Creamy Brownie Pudding Cake
    Creamy Brownie Pudding Cake

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Little Flaky Pumpkin Pies
    Little Flaky Pumpkin Pies

    Prep Time:
    40 minutes

  • Apple Custard Pie
    Apple Custard Pie

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes + 30 minutes chilling time

  • Very Berry Custard Pie
    Very Berry Custard Pie

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes, plus chilling time

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes

  • German Chocolate Cake
    German Chocolate Cake

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes + chilling time

  • Mini Chocolate Zucchini Muffins
    Mini Chocolate Zucchini Muffins

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Tarte au Sucre
    Tarte au Sucre

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes, plus 15 minutes refrigeration

  • Gingerbread Caramel Cupcakes
    Gingerbread Caramel Cupcakes

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes

  • Choco-Banana Bread Bites
    Choco-Banana Bread Bites

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Peanut Butter Chocolate Fudge
    Peanut Butter Chocolate Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

  • Green Tea Tofu Pudding
    Green Tea Tofu Pudding

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

    Cook Time:
    5 minutes

  • Pumpkin Spice Muffins
    Pumpkin Spice Muffins

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Carnation Herbed Cheese Spread
    Carnation Herbed Cheese Spread

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes, plus straining

    Cook Time:
    15 minutes

  • White Chocolate Cappuccino Fudge
    White Chocolate Cappuccino Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes, plus chilling time

    Cook Time:
    5 minutes

  • Dulce de Leche Fudge
    Dulce de Leche Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes, plus chilling time

    Cook Time:
    5 minutes

  • Chocolate Brown Sugar Fudge
    Chocolate Brown Sugar Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes, plus chilling time

    Cook Time:
    5 minutes

  • Chocolate Mousse Pudding
    Chocolate Mousse Pudding

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    12-15 minutes

  • Light as a Feather Angel Biscuits
    Light as a Feather Angel Biscuits

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes, plus 1 hour resting time

    Cook Time:
    13 minutes

  • Creamy Rice Pudding
    Creamy Rice Pudding

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    75-90 minutes

  • White Chocolate and Dried Cranberry Fudge
    White Chocolate and Dried Cranberry Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

  • Toasted Almond Bark Fudge
    Toasted Almond Bark Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

  • Chocolate Toffee Crunch Fudge
    Chocolate Toffee Crunch Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

  • Baked Berry Puff
    Baked Berry Puff

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Double Chocolate Cream Pie
    Double Chocolate Cream Pie

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes

  • Mango Pudding
    Mango Pudding

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

  • Sticky Toffee Pudding
    Sticky Toffee Pudding

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes

    Cook Time:
    40 to 45 minutes for cake, 10 minutes for sauce

  • Chocolate Bread Pudding with Chocolate Sauce
    Chocolate Bread Pudding with Chocolate Sauce

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Butterscotch Pudding Parfaits
    Butterscotch Pudding Parfaits

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes

  • 1-Dish Apple Streusel
    1-Dish Apple Streusel

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Toffee Crunch Crêpe Cake
    Toffee Crunch Crêpe Cake

    Prep Time:
    60 minutes

    Cook Time:
    40 minutes + 2 hours cooling

  • Applesauce Cake with Caramel Icing
    Applesauce Cake with Caramel Icing

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Caramel Apple Sticky Cake
    Caramel Apple Sticky Cake

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

  • Chocolate Chunk Vanilla Cake
    Chocolate Chunk Vanilla Cake

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

    Cook Time:
    45-50 minutes

  • Orange Walnut Loaf
    Orange Walnut Loaf

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

    Cook Time:
    55-60 minutes

  • Carnation Cookie Cutout Cake
    Carnation Cookie Cutout Cake

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

  • Carnation® Caramel Sauce
    Carnation® Caramel Sauce

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes

    Cook Time:
    5-7 minutes

  • Coconut Flan with Caribbean Treasure Sauce
    Coconut Flan with Caribbean Treasure Sauce

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

    Cook Time:
    35 minutes (flan), 5 minutes (sauce)

  • Caramel Latte
    Caramel Latte

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

  • Orange Cheesecake Bars
    Orange Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

    Cook Time:
    35 minutes

  • Apricot Panna Cotta
    Apricot Panna Cotta

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes + 2 hours chilling time

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes

  • Mini Sprinkle Cupcakes
    Mini Sprinkle Cupcakes

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

    Cook Time:
    17 minutes

  • Bread Machine Loaf
    Bread Machine Loaf
  • Ice Pops
    Ice Pops

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes

  • Luscious Lemony Dessert
    Luscious Lemony Dessert
  • Chocolate Orange Cheesecake Bars
    Chocolate Orange Cheesecake Bars
  • Chocolate Fondue
    Chocolate Fondue

    Cook Time:
    10 min

  • Chocolate Zucchini Bundt Cake
    Chocolate Zucchini Bundt Cake
  • Banana Bread Pudding
    Banana Bread Pudding
  • Luscious Cheesecake
    Luscious Cheesecake
  • Cobweb Fudge
    Cobweb Fudge
  • Chocolate Hazelnut Pudding
    Chocolate Hazelnut Pudding
  • Toffee Bars
    Toffee Bars
  • Quick Chocolate Fudge Sauce
    Quick Chocolate Fudge Sauce
  • Carnation® Traditional Scones
    Carnation® Traditional Scones
  • Carnation® Classic Pumpkin Pie
    Carnation® Classic Pumpkin Pie
  • Classic Five-Minute Fudge
    Classic Five-Minute Fudge

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes